Strict Standards: Declaration of KHttpUri::set() should be compatible with KObject::set($property, $value = NULL) in /www/htdocs/w006b358/libraries/koowa/http/uri.php on line 454

Strict Standards: Declaration of KHttpUri::get() should be compatible with KObject::get($property = NULL, $default = NULL) in /www/htdocs/w006b358/libraries/koowa/http/uri.php on line 454

Strict Standards: Non-static method JLoader::register() should not be called statically in /www/htdocs/w006b358/libraries/joomla/cache/cache.php on line 19

Strict Standards: Declaration of JCacheStorage::get() should be compatible with JObject::get($property, $default = NULL) in /www/htdocs/w006b358/libraries/joomla/cache/storage.php on line 173

Strict Standards: Non-static method JLoader::register() should not be called statically in /www/htdocs/w006b358/libraries/joomla/document/document.php on line 19

Strict Standards: Non-static method JLoader::import() should not be called statically in /www/htdocs/w006b358/libraries/loader.php on line 186

Strict Standards: Non-static method JLoader::import() should not be called statically in /www/htdocs/w006b358/libraries/loader.php on line 186

Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /www/htdocs/w006b358/libraries/koowa/http/uri.php:454) in /www/htdocs/w006b358/templates/ja_purity_ii/libs/ja.template.helper.php on line 130
What is your Opinion?

Bushdrums.com

You are here: Bush-Talk Forum General Information Wildlife Topics What is your Opinion?

Strict Standards: Declaration of ComNinjaHelperDefault::__call() should be compatible with KObject::__call($method, array $arguments) in /www/htdocs/w006b358/administrator/components/com_ninja/helpers/default.php on line 19

Strict Standards: Declaration of KControllerAbstract::__call() should be compatible with KObject::__call($method, array $arguments) in /www/htdocs/w006b358/libraries/koowa/controller/abstract.php on line 24

Strict Standards: Declaration of KViewTemplate::__call() should be compatible with KObject::__call($method, array $arguments) in /www/htdocs/w006b358/libraries/koowa/view/template.php on line 22

Strict Standards: Declaration of KModelAbstract::__call() should be compatible with KObject::__call($method, array $arguments) in /www/htdocs/w006b358/libraries/koowa/model/abstract.php on line 19

Strict Standards: Non-static method JLoader::register() should not be called statically in /www/htdocs/w006b358/administrator/components/com_ninja/models/settings.php on line 10

Strict Standards: Non-static method JLoader::import() should not be called statically in /www/htdocs/w006b358/libraries/loader.php on line 186

Strict Standards: Declaration of ComNinjaboardDatabaseTableSettings::_getDefaultsFromXML() should be compatible with ComNinjaDatabaseTableSettings::_getDefaultsFromXML() in /www/htdocs/w006b358/administrator/components/com_ninjaboard/databases/tables/settings.php on line 20

Strict Standards: Declaration of ComNinjaboardDatabaseTableAssets::insert() should be compatible with KDatabaseTableAbstract::insert(KDatabaseRowInterface $row) in /www/htdocs/w006b358/administrator/components/com_ninjaboard/databases/tables/assets.php on line 41

Strict Standards: Declaration of ComNinjaboardTemplateHelperPaginator::pagination() should be compatible with ComNinjaHelperPaginator::pagination($config = Array) in /www/htdocs/w006b358/components/com_ninjaboard/templates/helpers/paginator.php on line 13

Strict Standards: Non-static method JLoader::import() should not be called statically in /www/htdocs/w006b358/libraries/loader.php on line 186

What is your Opinion?

Link to this post 18 Oct 10

What is your opinion?

I recently saw a picture of a young elephant, one of three, that was involved in a hit and run accident near Buchuma Gate in Kenya. The person who took the picture said he had watched the female suffer moaning and groaning for 15 minutes before she died, with a ranger with a gun standing there and refusing to euthanize the animal and put her out of her misery.

I know there are two trains of thought on wildlife. Many of the conservationists feel that if an injury/illness is man-made then they will treat or euthanize. If it is a natural illness then they keep hands-off.

Assuming that a natural disaster is not involved such as drought where thousands of animals are dying, if you were in charge of conservation how would you handle different circumstances?

Snares/arrows/gunshot wounds
Fractures
Auto/train accidents
Foreign bodies causing infections
Infections without foreign bodies

If wildlife organizations decide not to treat/euthanize a suffering animal, would you continue to support the organization?

Link to this post 20 Oct 10

I do not have a cut & dried answer to this one, Jan.

Age of the animal, Quality of life, Risks involved to animal & to human life & regretfully the cost & rarity of the animal.
Each occurance should be judged on it's merit.

Taking into account the above here is my opinion for what it is worth.

Treated as a first option But how much damage to the animal has occured?
What are it's chances of a full recovery & a succesful life?
What are the likelyhood of repeat injury? ie:- Is it a crop raider or livestock killer?
How dangerous is it to the animal & vet to anaesthetise?

I think we do not have the option to do nothing, except for a fracture we have already played God - Treat or euthinize.

Link to this post 20 Oct 10

Kipper:

I agree with you 100%. You brought up the point of

regretfully the cost
, and I suspect that
is the biggest factor with wildlife in Africa. The governments don't supply enough funds for those taking care of wildlife. for instance, there is one veterinarian supplied by KWS through funds from the Sheldrick Trust and a European company that are donated to Tsavo East and West, Chyulu Hills, Amboseli and Shimba Hills. Another vet takes care of the Masai Mara and Rift Valley. Those are huge areas to be responsible for and oft times when they are needed in one area they are far away in another area. They do marvelous work but there are just not enough of them. I've been with the vet on several occasions and watched them work and they are to be truly commended. I just wish there were more of them.

There usually isn't much danger to the animal to anesthetize. The vets are real pros and know the correct dosages of M99 to give each species. When I've watched them dart elephants the vets were always in a vehicle to do the darting and only when the animal goes down does everyone scramble out of the vehicle to get the animal correctly positioned and treat, and then after the antidote is given the vet doesn't leave until the animal is up and walking away.

I know of one elephant I first saw in 2001 with a severely fractured right back leg that had obviously healed incorrectly and was badly bent, but he managed to get around fine despite the injury and get his food and water. I saw him again three years later and he was still doing fine. Then another two years later he showed up right beside my tent (about 40 miles from where I had first seen him) and I was happy to see he was managing alright. In this case, though there was no treatment, the animal did well on its own.

However, there are cases of animals suffering greatly who can't possibly survive their severe injuries, who could easily be put out of their pain and suffering by wildlife organizations such as KWS and sometimes nothing is done. I find this very difficult to understand. Can the cost of a bullet be that great in Africa? Is the paper work entailed when one euthanizes an animal too much to do? In the case of the small elephant family involved in the hit and run accident and left dying beside the road, I would probably have wrestled the gun from the KWS ranger, euthanized the animal and then been arrested for taking the gun from the wildlife authority.

It is too bad there isn't some way that we could get wealthy veterinarians from the US and Europe to donate some of their funds to helping care for wildlife in other parts of the world where it is so badly needed.
It is so difficult seeing suffering, whether from humans or wildlife, but like you I think treat or euthanize.

Link to this post 30 Oct 10

- if people inflicted the wound humans should care and either treat the animal up until recovery - whatever it takes! - or euthanize in case a full recovery is unlikely and to put a qick end to misery.

- if natural cause then nature should take its course but only if it's not an threatened or endangered species.